What I Learned from taking a traditional Nutrition Course…and What I Didn’t Learn
I recently completed the Nutrition, Health, and Lifestyle: Issues and Insights Course at Vanderbilt University’s School of Nursing. It was an extremely insightful experience to see what a traditional Nutritionist learns and eventually coaches or advocates to their clients.
All information in this article is for educational purposes only.
It is not for the diagnosis, treatment, prescription or cure of any disease or health condition.
I decided that it would be a unique “cultural exchange” to experience what traditional Nutritionists learn. Although I did learn a few useful things that I will outline below, for the most part I was shocked and disappointed to see the mis-truths and lack of unbiased information being presented to the students. Well, we all know that industry sponsors many universities through expensive grants, so could we really expect these teaching institutions to maintain an impartial perspective?
Many times during the course, I felt like I was being fed propaganda created directly by the food industry and/or Monsanto themselves. I actually feel bad for anyone who spends the money on a 4-year Nutrition Degree, because they may enter their study with high hopes of helping others, but how can they really help guide others through nutrition and diet when they are being taught lies? It’s truly a shame to see a system that is so broken and so far away from the relevance of a real natural, whole and pure diet and its effect on one’s health.
What I Learned
As I mentioned above, there were a few things that I learned from this course, or at least that I felt were truthful and relevant. They include:
-Professor showed several studies comparing a vegetarian diet to meat-based diet and how vegetarians have reduced risk of cancer, diabetes, etc.
-Professor mentioned that, “Even though we are living longer in the US, we are also living sicker.” I would agree!
-Professional explained superfoods, nutrient-dense foods, phyto-chemicals and importance of nutrients in the diet. Obviously this is important, and was factual in the course.
-Professor cited a study that showed vegan and vegetarian diet offer significant benefit in diabetes management. Additionally, it was pointed out that vegan and vegetarian diets also improve plasma lipid concentrations and have been shown to reverse atherosclerosis progression.
-Professor cited the position of the American Dietetic Association that “appropriately planned vegetarian diets, including total vegetarian or vegan diets, are healthful, nutritionally adequate, and may provide health benefits in the prevention and treatment of certain diseases.”
-Professor discussed the importance on B12 and Omega 3 Fatty Acids in a vegetarian and/or vegan diet. Certainly important factors to consider, and should be addressed for meat-eaters too!
-Professor accurately showed the excess of salt, fat and sugar in the Standard American Diet and the related high obesity rates in the United States.
Clearly these facts cannot be denied!
In summary, some good information about the benefits of a vegetarian and/or vegan diet was presented, and some factual information on obesity and the lack of fruits and vegetables in the Standard American (SAD) Diet was mentioned.
The other parts of the course are where I found myself wincing and shaking my head in utter dismay.
What I Didn’t Learn
Most notable items not addressed, under-addressed or mis-addressed in this course:
-Professor downplayed any danger associated with GMO (Genetically Modified Organism) foods, saying that “GMO has been around for centuries and centuries” and then stated that GMO has been around for “thousands of years.”
How did they isolate proteins in labs thousands of years ago exactly?
-Professor mentioned soy as a complete protein but of course no mention that 94% of soy in the USA is GMO and no mention or even peep about consuming GMO foods in relation to higher risk of infertility and food allergies.
Isn’t this of utmost importance when working with people and the nutritional relevance of their diet to health?
-Professor stated that, “Consumers may need to educate themselves before they jump on the bandwagon of something that they don’t understand,” and went on to add that with GMO foods “we are feeding areas of the world that don’t have the distribution and supply that we have.”
Spoon-fed propaganda from Monsanto PR…or what?
Anyone who is working with nutrition and food allergies, autism, ADHD and infertility (all of which have completed skyrocketed in the last decade worldwide) knows that something has seriously gone wrong.
If you are unsure in any way, please watch these documentaries on GMO foods and health: “The World According to Monsanto,” “Food, Inc.,” “The Future of Food,” “Seeds of Freedom,” “Genetic Roulette,” “Scientists Under Attack,” and “The GMO Trilogy.” Some of these documentaries can be watched for FREE online at http://topdocumentaryfilms.com/.
I also highly recommend the book The Unhealthy Truth: How Our Food is Making Us Sick and What We Can Do About It by Robyn O’Brien for extensively researched information and links to studies on GMO foods and food allergies. An excellent read for anyone looking to learn more on the subject of GMO foods and health!
Yes, it is true that we need to educate ourselves!
-Professor downplayed importance of organic foods, stating that “an organic apple is not going to be more nutritious than a conventionally grown apple.”
No mention of pesticides, GMO proteins or the simple fact that organic soil has more nutrients in the soil. How, why?? How can a “qualified” Nutritionist ignore the nutritional value of organic food?
In fact, reviews of multiple studies show that organic varieties do provide significantly greater levels of vitamin C, iron, magnesium, and phosphorus than non-organic varieties of the same foods (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20359265).
-Professor advocated the use of “fortified foods” as a way to increase nutrient consumption, specifically advocating milk fortified with Vitamin D, fortified breakfast cereals, and fortified sports drinks like Gatorade.
Why ignore the value of organic whole foods yet advocate processed foods that are chemically fortified with inorganic vitamins and minerals? No mention of the antibiotics and hormones in conventional milk, the added sugar in breakfast cereals or the chemical colorings in sports drinks. Wow.
-Professor downplayed the dangers of chemical food additives in the diet.
In my professional experience, more people are being affected by all types of food additives more than ever before, because food additives are being used in food more than ever before!
Flavor enhancers (MSG, ribonucleotide), nitrates, sulfites, aspartame and other artificial sweeteners and chemical colorings are creating an absolute health epidemic! To gloss over this issue and to not acknowledge the danger of food additives in relation to nutrition and health is both irresponsible and just plain idiotic. I’m truly devastated to see the education so lacking on this topic. Sadly, the food industry has a lot of money to hide the truth.
Because Monosodium Glutamate was used in foods before 1958, the FDA considers it as “Generally Recognized as Safe” or GRAS. Other foods which are categorized as GRAS are salt, pepper, vinegar and baking powder. How is it possible that MSG is considered as safe as vinegar? And hasn’t the amounts of concentrations of MSG increased in foods since 1958, making it a higher risk contaminant and something that should be re-evaluated in the interest of public health and safety?
The worst part of all is that this is what Nutritionists are learning in school. Will they be able to identify an MSG intolerance in their client? Chances are extremely slim, because they are taught that MSG is “safe!” I cannot count how many clients I have worked with suffering from migraines, insomnia, depression, heart palpitations, anxiety, vertigo, itchy rashes, puffiness, sensitivity to light and sound and even behavioral and learning problems in children: all of which were reversed when we removed MSG and/or Ribonucleotides and all hidden forms of MSG out of the diet.
You cannot advise people on food and not take into account the potential effect of chemical food additives!
-Professor spoke with David McCarty, Senior VP Operations of Smart Balance spreads for 30 minutes and praised his product line for being a good source of Omega 3 Fatty Acids and for being a “heart-friendly” food.
Smart Balance “butter” is not something that I even consider a FOOD!
What is natural about spreadable butter containing genetically modified (GMO) soy and artificial flavor which is surely where they are hiding the salty, savory flavor enhancers and/or some hidden form of MSG to actually give this greasy mess some type of taste that is palatable to humans?
If you are a non-vegan, you are much better off eating REAL butter with 2 simple ingredients: butter and salt. I am amazed to see Smart Balance call itself a “heart healthy” food when Monosodium Glutamate (MSG) is known to cause heart palpitations. People may eat this mess and think they are having a heart attack!
Vegans can simply use extra-virgin olive oil, an organic almond butter or tahini (sesame seed) paste. People on a raw food vegan diet will not need any spread to put on bread, and they can use fresh lime or lime for salad dressing and add tahini to a raw cracker. Easy!
To summarize, I do not feel that I wasted my time by taking a traditional nutrition class. Actually, I would recommend it to anyone working with nutrition, diet, people and food. It’s important to know what the “mainstream” teaches in order to have a better understanding of what your client may have faced previously by seeing a traditional nutritionist in the past.
That said, there still may be some nutritionists who think and learn outside of the box and may actually have an awareness of other factors that affect food and health, mainly GMO foods, quality of food (organic vs. conventional) and the relation of food additives to health. As a client, the best thing to do is to check your nutritionist’s website or ask them if they will go to the level of food additives and food quality during your session. If they reply that their approach is centered only around protein, carbs, fats, minerals and vitamins, then please take my advice: keep shopping until you find someone who will go deeper to help you have the best health ever…because you deserve the very best, in food and in health!
For information on how to work with me for Your Best Health, please go to my Coaching Page.
More on Healthy Living:
- How to Make Almond Milk or Seed Milk at Home
- Intermittent fasting – What’s the best way?
- How to Eat Out and Order Raw Food in Normal Restaurants
- Super Energy Raw Cabbage Salad Recipe – A mini-detox meal
- Raw Food, Vegan and Organic Options in Seoul, Korea
Latest posts by Jennifer Betesh (see all)
- What is an elimination diet? - 28 March, 2019
- Intermittent fasting – What’s the best way? - 15 March, 2019
- How do you know when it’s time to STOP fasting - 28 February, 2019
- When is the BEST time (and WORST time) to START a detox - 20 February, 2019
I just came upon your website while researching ways to rid myself of an aspartame addiction. While I have a mild interest in nutrition, it wasn’t enough to make me wary and now I’m paying the price.
It’s thanks to people like yourself that I will be able to regain my health. You have a new fan.
I have been looking at Dr. Joel Wallach’s (He is the author of “Dead Doctors don’t Lie) You Tube videos. His credentials include BS, DVM and MD he is very learned on the topic of nutrition. He has defeated the FDA 7 times in court. If you view the video Cholesterol Myths you will see a slide of his accomplishments. He has performed thousands of autopsies on animal and humans alike to conclude that people die of nutritional and vitamin deficiencies. I totally agree with the author’s conclusion that it is a waste of time and money to take college courses on nutrition. I’m fairly confident to say that you can learn more watching these video’s than all the college courses in the USA combined.
Response like Allison’s above should be merely deleted. There is a place for allowing all “opinions” and a time when that is destructive. This is the latter.
People reading her blather will be misled further into a life of misinformed eating. The thinking being that if their nutritionist is suggesting something un-healthy but has Monsanto gobbedly gook behind it, it might be okay.
There’s really only ONE safe way of eating. And that is food that hasn’t been effed with, of the proper quantities at the proper times.
What goes into the body should not be determined by “research”. It should be determined by our maker, who obviously created the body to work optimally with what He/She planned would be present on the Earth during the reign of mankind.
If that’s not simple, I don’t know what is.
I just took the same course on the Coursera website, and I have to agree with you. I think the whole GMO issue is due to nutritionists not having a very good grasp on evolution and genetics. Same holds true for doctors. Evolution is vital to understanding life.
I am a biologist and this bugs me to death.
Great post and follow up. GMO’s are everywhere and the world needs to wake the hell up. I am enrolled at IIN in NYC and they address the GMO problem, I am impressed. Very well rounded and un-biased. This year long course will put me on my new path from school counselor to health counselor.
Keep up the good work! I am staying tuned for sure!
Thank you so much for this review. Good on you for putting in the time it takes to attend and review the course. My friend who studied Dietetics at a University in Australia has the same opinion as you. She has said that the only way she was able to help people was to re-educate herself in nutrition once she had graduated and she estimates she now uses less than 1% of what she learnt at uni because it was plain old wrong!! It’s good to acknowledge that the people starting these courses usually do it because they want to help people and unfortunately are not able to as they are told lies and propaganda rather than quality information. There is a saying that if you are happy with mainstream thinking you are already 20 years behind current research. Thanks again.
Thanks for sharing your story!
To your health,
It seems to me you are far more biased than the presenters at Vanderbilt. Actually, I like your blog and website, but I find your attack on the field of dietetics to be totally distasteful. Dietetics is based on sound science, not on best guesses. For instance, we think that GMO’s may have a negative long term impact on health, but we don’t KNOW that; there are no peer reviewed studies to conclusively link them to infertility. It’s also hogwash how you make it sound like all the evidence out there shows organic produce being more nutrition; despite the “few” studies that you quoted, a metaanalysis (the mother of scientific lit reviews) was recently released to show that across the board, there is not a significant nutritional difference between organic and nonorganic produce. Look, I make a huge effort myself and drive an extra 30 minutes on my way home from work everyday to buy organic produce; I think it’s important a for the environment and I want to reduce the pesticide load in my body… but at least I am honest with myself and others about the benefits… MAYBE there is some extra nutrition in some of the organic produce I buy, but not necessarily. Basically, all of your arguments lack credibility and it detracts from the good information that you provide readers with. I just feel very sad right now.
It’s a very idealistic and unrealistic concept to think that current science funding and studies are unbiased, and that is the saddest part of all of this.
It’s true that I did not offer a lot of links to prove my points, because in my world this is such common knowledge and it is so completely obvious that the industry-controlled media is spoon-feeding lies to the general sheeple who simply believe whatever lie they are told. Well, it’s like wasting time proving that we need oxygen in air to breathe!
In relation to GMOs, I encourage you and everyone to watch all of the documentaries on GMOs that I listed in the article, and then make your opinion about GMO and health. There will be no doubt in anyone who is still capable of having an independent thought.
One of the most significant GMO study relating GMO food to infertility was done by GM food safety expert Dr. Arpad Pusztai. “In 1998, Pusztai expressed his concerns about GM foods on a British television program and was promptly suspended and forced to retire from his position. Dr. Pusztai’s research was later peer reviewed and published in The Lancet, a leading British medical journal.” (http://www.organicconsumers.org/articles/article_18101.cfm)
Here are some additional links on GMO foods and health and environment:
New Study Links Genetically Engineering Corn to Infertility: http://www.organicconsumers.org/articles/article_15588.cfm
French Study Finds Massive Tumors And Organ Damage in Rats Fed GMOs: http://laist.com/2012/09/19/french_study_finds_massive_tumors_i.php?fb_action_ids=10151162398593555
Doctors Warn: Avoid Genetically Modified Food: http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2010/03/25/doctors-warn-avoid-genetically-modified-food.aspx
Health and Environmental Hazards Associated with Genetically Modified Foods: http://www.seattleorganicrestaurants.com/vegan-whole-foods/fact-checking-gmo-foods/
Monsanto’s Best-Selling Herbicide Roundup Linked to Infertility: http://naturalsociety.com/monsantos-best-selling-herbicide-roundup-linked-to-infertility/
US Fertility in Decline: http://www.prb.org/Articles/2011/us-fertility-decline.aspx
I also highly recommend the book “The Unhealthy Truth: How Our Food is Making Us Sick and What We Can Do About It” by Robyn O’Brien for extensively researched information and links to studies on GMO foods and food allergies. An excellent read for anyone looking to learn more on the subject of GMO foods and health!
It is important to understand that industry lobbyists are paying government agencies billions of dollars to defend their profit-based policies. That means that the government will officially say that there is no negative impact on health from GMO food because they have been paid to do so!! Any scientist who tries to question that has been fired (watch the documentary “Scientists Under Attack”). Everyone knows that Monsanto has a revolving door between its employees and the FDA.
Remember that Monsanto is the same company that told us Agent Orange, PCBs and DDT were safe. Are you really going to believe them again??
If you are really concerned for the environment, you would be protesting against GMO seeds and GMO foods every day! Your organic produce will no longer be an option once Monsanto owns the patent to every seed and only offer GMO seeds to be sold. Pull the wool off your eyes…there is no more time to waste!